Market · Williamsburg
Heatonist
Some booking links are affiliate links. If you book through them, we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. We never let this influence which places we recommend.
Heatonist is a mecca for hot sauce enthusiasts, located on Wythe Avenue in the heart of Williamsburg. The shop is compact but packed with shelves of carefully curated hot sauces, each with a story. From small-batch American craft sauces to exotic imports, every bottle is selected for flavor and quality, not just heat. The staff are passionate and knowledgeable, offering tastings and recommendations based on your tolerance and taste preferences. You'll find everything from smoky chipotle blends to fruity habanero concoctions and super-hot extracts. The shop also hosts tasting events and collaborations with local chefs. What makes Heatonist distinctive is its role in the hot sauce community, it's a destination for discovering new brands and connecting with fellow spice lovers. The minimalist, modern interior lets the colorful bottles shine, and the friendly atmosphere makes it easy to spend time browsing and sampling.
Don't miss
- Curated selection of over 100 hot sauces from around the world
- Free tastings to help you find your perfect sauce
- Exclusive collaborations with top hot sauce makers
- Knowledgeable staff who love talking about heat and flavor
Tickets & tours
Ways to visit Heatonist
You don't need a tour to visit — entry is free. A tour is worth it if you want transport, a guide, or to combine Heatonist with nearby sights in one day. That's what these do well.
Cheapest way inPrivate Brooklyn Bridge Tour with a Local5★ · 11 travelers~2 hoursFree cancellationFrom$20 per personSee dates →
Best full dayNYC Bus Tour of Brooklyn, Bronx, Queens: Art, Food & Sports4.9★ · 4,181 travelers~6 hoursFree cancellationFrom$69 per personSee dates →
Private & flexibleBrooklyn Street Art, Bridges & Skyline Tour4.9★ · 58 travelers~2 hoursFree cancellationFrom$65 per personSee dates →Good for
How travelers rate it
Know before you go
- Don't be shy, ask for a taste of any sauce that catches your eye.
- They offer shipping if you can't carry bottles home.
- Credit cards are accepted.
- Start mild and work your way up if you're not a heat veteran.
A bit of history
Heatonist opened in 2016 as a brick-and-mortar extension of an online hot sauce subscription service, quickly becoming a go-to spot for artisanal hot sauces in New York City.
Common questions
Can I sample sauces before buying?
Yes, they offer free tastings of most sauces.
Do they have super-hot sauces?
Yes, including sauces with Carolina Reaper and ghost pepper.
Is there parking nearby?
Street parking is limited; public transit is recommended.
Do they sell online?
Yes, they have an online store with nationwide shipping.
Are there any vegan sauces?
Many sauces are vegan; check labels or ask staff.
Can I find sauces from specific regions?
Yes, they carry sauces from the US, Mexico, Caribbean, Africa, and more.
More attractions in Brooklyn
